Announcement: We were named to Inc. 5000 fastest growing companies in America!

10 Things to Consider Before Hiring an SEO Company for Your Law Firm

Choosing the right SEO company for your law firm is a direct investment in long-term visibility, client acquisition, and competitiveness. A skilled partner can help your firm rank across Google, Bing, and new AI-driven search platforms, allowing you to attract high-value cases and build the authority modern search engines reward. Selecting the wrong agency, however, can lead to wasted budgets, declining rankings, and lost opportunities.

This guide outlines the most important elements to consider when hiring an SEO company for your law firm, based on today’s evolving landscape across traditional search and LLM-powered tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Bing AI.

Hire an SEO company for Your Law Firm

1. Proven Experience in Legal SEO (Not Just Any Industry)

Experience in legal SEO is essential because the legal industry is far more competitive than most others. Personal injury, criminal defense, family law, immigration law, and employment law all attract high-value cases and require in-depth knowledge of user intent, compliant content, and local search patterns.

A provider should demonstrate real performance in competitive metros, including proven rankings for terms like:

  • Personal injury lawyer Los Angeles
  • Car accident lawyer Atlanta
  • Divorce attorney Houston
  • Employment lawyer NYC

These results show the agency can succeed in challenging environments. Attorney Marketing Network has consistently delivered results across PI, mass torts, family law, immigration, and criminal defense, proving that legal-focused SEO outperforms generalist agencies.

2. Local SEO vs. Organic SEO and Why You Need Both

Both Local SEO and Organic SEO are essential to a successful legal marketing strategy because they serve different but equally important functions.

Local SEO for Lawyers

Local SEO focuses on Google Business Profile optimization, Maps rankings, proximity signals, reviews, and NAP accuracy. These elements help your firm appear when someone needs immediate legal help, whether for a personal injury emergency, a criminal matter, or an urgent family law issue.

Organic SEO for Lawyers

Organic SEO supports long-term visibility with long-form content, practice area pages, internal linking, schema, backlinks, and E E A T signals. This side of SEO helps your firm show up for legal research queries, statewide searches, and broader informational needs.

Both channels work together. Local SEO drives immediate leads, while Organic SEO builds sustained authority and ongoing traffic over time.

3. Why Hire an SEO Company for Your Law Firm

Hiring an SEO company gives your firm access to specialized skills that would be difficult to maintain internally. Legal SEO requires technical audits, structured content, competitor analysis, link building, schema, conversion optimization, and monthly refinement across both local and organic channels.

A legal-focused agency brings all of these components together into a unified strategy. With the right partner, you gain:

This creates consistent momentum and long-term growth that internal teams often struggle to achieve.

4. In-House SEO vs. Hiring Attorney Marketing Network

In-house SEO vs hiring Attorney Marketing Network

Many firms consider building an in-house team but quickly discover how costly and time-consuming it becomes. A complete SEO operation requires hiring:

  • a strategist
  • a writer
  • technical SEO specialist
  • a designer
  • a developer
  • a link-building resource
  • a reporting analyst

Combined salaries, management, training, and software often exceed $250,000 per year, yet the work remains fragmented across multiple roles.

Hiring Attorney Marketing Network solves these issues. Firms get immediate access to:

  • Significantly lower cost
  • Proven legal industry performance
  • Immediate execution
  • No training or hiring
  • Full team included
  • Established processes
  • Scalable growth

AMN eliminates the complexity of internal management and provides scalable execution at a fraction of the cost.

5. The Benefits of SEO for Law Firms

SEO is one of the only marketing channels that increases in value over time. While PPC stops the moment a budget pauses, SEO continues driving results month after month. High rankings reduce your cost per case, strengthen brand credibility, and increase calls from both Local Pack and organic results.

Additional long-term benefits include:

  • Lower cost per case
  • Consistent lead generation
  • Strong client trust
  • Improved visibility across channels

SEO forms the foundation of sustainable digital growth for law firms.

6. SEO is No Longer Just Google: The Rise of LLM Search

Search behavior now extends beyond Google. Clients use tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Bing AI to research legal issues, compare attorneys, and get quick summaries. These platforms rely heavily on content quality, structured data, brand mentions, and strong authority signals.

If your firm lacks structured content, citations, and optimized pages, LLMs may not recognize you as a reliable source. Your SEO company must understand how to build authority that resonates across both traditional and AI-powered search.

Website Traffic Comes from LLM Search

7. How Much Search Traffic LLMs Are Capturing Today

LLM-driven search is still emerging but growing faster than any prior search technology. Users rely on AI tools for research, comparison, and early evaluation, but still return to Google and Bing for final decisions. This makes LLM visibility an essential complement to traditional SEO.
Current trends show:

  • Less than one percent of traffic comes from LLM search
  • Ninety-five percent of AI users still rely heavily on Google
  • LLM searches are primarily research-focused

Traditional SEO remains essential, but LLM optimization forms the next strategic layer.

8. Can You Rank on Google Without Doing SEO?

Ranking on Google without a structured SEO strategy is almost impossible in competitive legal markets. Even high-quality content cannot perform if the foundational SEO elements are missing. Google continues to raise its standards, and most LLMs surface content that already ranks well organically. Without proper optimization, your pages struggle to index, gain authority, or appear in AI-driven results.

Key SEO elements your website still needs include:

  • Meta Data
  • Heading Structure
  • Internal linking
  • Schema markup
  • Backlinks
  • Site speed optimization
  • E E A T signals
  • Local citations
  • Optimized GBP
  • Mobile speed
  • Authority signals
  • Sitemap File Creation
  • Robots File Creation
  • LLMs.txt File Creation
  • Performance Tracking and Improvement

Websites without these essentials typically remain invisible. Issues such as:

  • Lack of citations
  • Poor mobile performance
  • Thin practice area pages
  • Inconsistent branding

All prevent your content from earning trust in both Google and LLM ecosystems. Even informative content will not appear on AI-powered platforms unless it is properly indexed, structured, and optimized for SEO. Traditional SEO remains the foundation for gaining visibility across all modern search environments.

9. Why Bing Suddenly Matters for Lawyers

Bing has become more important because many AI platforms, including ChatGPT and CoPilot, pull real-time data from Bing’s index. Even if clients do not search on Bing directly, their AI tools often do.

Ranking well on Bing expands your firm’s reach into multiple AI ecosystems, improving your chances of appearing in summaries, recommendations, and attorney comparisons.

10. Brand Mentions and Authority Signals in LLMs

Brand mentions and authority signals in llms

LLMs depend on entity recognition, structured data, citations, reviews, press mentions, internal linking, and authoritative backlinks. These signals help AI systems determine whether a law firm is credible and safe to recommend.

Agencies without legal experience often overlook these signals, but specialized teams know how to build and maintain them effectively.

How Each Major LLM Evaluates Law Firms

What LLM Should We Focus on for SEO result

Each LLM uses its own logic, but all rely on structured accuracy and authority.

  • Google AI Overviews focuses on depth, organization, backlinks, and E E A T
  • ChatGPT prioritizes legal citations and sources accessible through Bing
  • Perplexity emphasizes citation-based credibility
  • Gemini favors long-form content and organized topic clusters
  • Bing AI and CoPilot rely on entity recognition and authority signals

Without strong SEO fundamentals, your content is less likely to be surfaced by these systems.

What This Means for Your Law Firm

To compete today, your firm must be visible across Google, Bing, and AI-driven platforms. Strong Local SEO, Organic SEO, structured content, schema, citations, and brand consistency are now mandatory. Firms that invest in both traditional and AI-focused SEO gain an advantage that compounds over time.

Why Attorney Marketing Network Gives Your Firm an Advantage

Attorney Marketing Network brings more than fifteen years of exclusive legal marketing experience, helping firms rank in competitive markets nationwide. Their team includes legally trained writers, technical specialists, link-building experts, and strategists focused solely on the legal sector.

AMN delivers optimized performance across Google, Bing, and LLM discovery while providing transparent reporting and a long-term growth framework. For firms seeking sustainable authority and signed cases, AMN offers one of the most effective solutions available.

Related Links:

Ready To Build Your Practice?

We're here to help you thrive in the legal world. Whether you're just starting out or looking to expand, our expert team at Attorney Marketing Network has the tools and strategies to boost your practice to new heights.

Book A Consultation